Is Photography Art?

SHARE:

The controversy about whether photography is art is one that has been raging in the art world for a long time and we are not likely to total...

photographyid.blogspot.com
The controversy about whether photography is art is one that has been raging in the art world for a long time and we are not likely to totally solve it here.  But it can be an important decision you have to make if you are considering a career in photography with the goal of producing quality art works.  If that is where you are, the idea that someone would say “That’s not art, you just took a picture” is pretty disturbing.  So it’s worth looking at the question from several different angles before we pick which side to weigh in on.

Of course, art is a subjective thing.  Many people would look at a Jackson Pollack “splatter” artwork and determine most definitely that modern art is not art because it “doesn’t look like anything.”  And if you spend any time in the modern art world, you will definitely see something at some time along the way occupying space in a perfectly respectable art museum that, to you, could never be considered art.

So is it just a matter of opinion?  To some extent, yes.  But there is an art world and an industry behind it that depend on there being some standards upon which art is judged.  One such standard is the intent of the artist.  If you produce a photograph or an art work derived from a photograph that is intended to be viewed as art, then the viewer is obligated to try to see the artistic merit in it.  Whether the viewer sees that merit or not may depend on the viewer’s abilities, how good you are at getting your artistic message across or many other factors.

But just wanting something to be art doesn’t make it art does it?  As a layman in the art world, I sometimes go with the “I don’t know art but I know what I like” system of evaluating pieces I see.  Art, after all, has a tendency to touch us in another place that is above and beyond the image.  It is an emotional place, a place of reflection and understanding.  Maybe we would say it touches our “soul”.  For a work to be art, there should be a message, a feeling, a reason the artist made the work because he or she wanted to say something, even if how I interpret the statement is different than what the artist meant.  

So that might also be an evaluation of a photograph as to its artistic merit or not.  Now the primary objection to whether photography is art sometimes is that a photograph is often a realistic depiction of a moment taken with a machine and some would say that “anybody can take a picture.”  The implication is that the same mechanical skill it might take to paint a picture of sculpt a statue is not needed for photographic art.

It’s true that the mechanical skill that the guy at Wal-Mart might need to take baby pictures may be the same as a great photographic artist might need.  But the objection doesn’t hold up because the same human language is used to create great poetry as it takes yell out obscenities at a baseball game.  So it isn’t the skill that makes it art.  

Good evidence comes from the credit some great art experts have given to photographic exhibitions in the fine museums in the world.  The very fact that photography is considered art by those who know may be evidence enough.  So the conclusion must be that because the arguments against the artistic value of photographs are weak and people who know consider photography to be art, then we are safe in viewing what we do artistically too.  And that opens up that side of your soul to express yourself through the medium you love the most – photography.

COMMENTS

Name

51 species,1,Acorn Woodpecker,1,Adonis Blue,1,Alners Gorse,2,American Redstart,1,American Robin,1,Audouin's Gull,4,Avocet,3,Axe Estuary,1,Azure-Winged Magpie,2,Badbury Rings,1,Bar-tailed Godwit,1,Barn Owl,3,Barn Swallow,27,Barnacle Goose,5,Bath,3,Bearded tit,3,Beautiful Demoiselle,1,beauty indonesia,3,Bee-Eater,4,belajar kamera,2,Belted Kingfisher,1,Bentley wood,1,Bewick Swan,5,Birds,1,Bittern,7,Black Guillemot,2,Black headed gull,5,Black Redstart,1,Black Tailed Godwit,2,Black Tern,2,Black-Tailed Godwit,1,Black-Winged Stilt,3,Blackbird,2,Blackcap,21,Blagdon Lake,1,Blue Jay,1,Blue Rock Thrush,1,Blue Tit,3,Blyth's Pipit,2,boathouse,1,boathouse loop,1,Booted Eagle,2,Bradley Stoke,1,Brambling,1,Brent Goose,2,Brimstone,5,Bristol,1,Broad Bodied Chaser,1,Brown Argus,2,Brown Hairstreak,1,Bullfinch,25,Bullfinch.,1,Butterflies,9,Butterfly,4,Buzzard,63,Buzzard.,1,Buzzard.patch,1,Camera Review,6,Canada Goose,1,Catcott,1,Cattle Egret,2,Cattle Egret's,1,Cerne abbas,1,Cetti's Warbler,5,Chaffinch,3,Chalkhill Blue,3,cheddar,1,Cheddar Reservoir,2,Chequered Skipper,1,Chew valley,4,Chew Valley Lake,3,Chiffchaff,35,Coal Tit,14,Coal Tit. Dragonflies,1,Coastal,1,Collared Dove,3,Collared Dove and Woodpigeon,1,Collared Pratincole,1,Comma,5,Common Blue,4,Common Crane,5,Common Eider,1,Common Gull,11,Common Redstart,1,Common Redstarts,1,Common Sandpiper,4,Common Tern,1,Common Yellowthroat,1,Coot,3,Coot! Patch,1,Cormorant,3,Corn Bunting,3,Corvids,1,Cotley hill,2,Crested Coot,3,Crested Lark,2,Crook Peak,2,Crow,3,Cryptic Wood White,2,Cuckoo,2,Curlew,6,Curlew Sandpiper,2,Cygnets,2,Dark Eyed Junco,1,Dark Green Fritillaries,1,Dark Green Fritillary,1,Dark green Fritillary.,1,Dartford Warbler,2,Dingy Skipper,3,Dipper,1,Dorset,2,Downy Woodpecker,1,Dragonfly,1,draycott,1,Draycott Sleights,1,Duke Burgundy,1,Dunlin,13,Dunnock,2,Durdle Door,1,editing,75,Egyptian Goose.,1,Eider,2,Eleanora Falcon,2,Elegant Tern,1,Eleonora Falcon,1,Elephant Hawk Moth,1,Essex Skipper,3,Farmoor,2,feeders,1,Female Blackcap,1,Feral,1,Fermyn,1,Fieldfare,5,Firecrest,1,Flamingo,1,Fledglings,1,Flood,1,FOD,1,Fontmell,2,Fontmell Down,1,Forest Of Dean,1,fotografi,75,Fulmar,1,Gadwall,7,Garganey,2,Gatekeeper,5,Gatekeepers,1,Glanville,1,Glanville.,1,Glaucous Gull,1,Glossy Ibis,6,Godwit,1,Goldcrest,12,Golden Plover,3,Goldeneye,2,Goldfinch,8,Goosander,16,Goshawk,1,grayling,2,Great Crested Grebe,1,Great Northern Diver,1,Great Reed Warbler,3,Great Spotted Woodpecker,1,Great Tit,3,Great White Egret,10,Greater Black Backed Gull,1,Greater Black-Backed Gull,1,Greater Flamingo,1,Greater Spotted Cuckoo,1,Greater Spotted Wood,1,Greater Spotted Woodpecker,13,Greater Yellowlegs,1,Green,1,Green Hairstreak,1,Green Veined White,3,Green Wood,3,Green Woodpecker,12,Green Woodpeckers,1,Greenfinch,8,Greenshank,3,Grey and Pied,1,Grey Catbird,2,Grey Heron,6,Grey Plover,1,Grey Wag,1,Grey Wagtail,25,Greylag,1,Greylake,2,Grizzled Skipper,3,GS Wood,1,GSpecker,1,Hairstreak,1,Ham Wall,4,Hamwall,1,Hawfinch,1,Heath Fritillary,1,Herring Gull,3,High Brown,1,Higher Heath,1,Hobby,4,Holly Blue,4,Hooded Crow,1,Hoopoe,2,hornet,1,House Martin,19,House Martin Barn Swallow,1,House Martins,3,House Sparrow,7,Iceland Gull,1,informasi,25,jasa perawat,1,jasa perawat home care,1,jasa perawat home care terbaik di indonesia,1,Jay,13,Jay.,1,kamera dslr,2,Kentish Plover,3,Kestrel,35,Kestrel.,1,Kestrel. Butterflies: Small Tortoiseshell,1,Kingfisher,23,Kittiwake,1,Lapwing,3,Large Blue,2,Large Heath,1,Large Red,1,Large Skipper,2,Large Skipper.Bentley wood,1,Large White,3,Larger Skipper,1,Laughing Gull,1,LBB gull,1,Lesser Black Backed,3,Lesser Black Backed Gull,2,Lesser Whitethroat,1,Lesser YellowLegs,3,Linnet,18,Linnet 5 Greenfinch,1,Linnet.,1,Little Bittern,2,Little Bittern (heard),1,Little Egret,8,Little Grebe,9,Little Gull,1,Little Owl,5,Little Stint,3,Lizards,1,Lodmoor,4,Long Tailed Tits,1,Long-Tailed Duck,1,Long-Tailed Tit,1,Lrg/Small whites,1,Lulworth Skipper,2,Magpie,5,Mandarin Duck,2,Marbled duck,1,Marbled White,5,Marsh Fritillary,1,Marsh Frits,1,Marsh Harrier,10,Marsh Harriers,1,Marsh Tit,10,Marsh Tit.teal,1,Marsh Tits,1,marshfield,2,Martin Down NR,1,Meadow Brown,5,Meadow Brown.,1,Meadow Pipit,10,Med Gull,1,Mediterranean Gull,3,mendips,1,Mink,1,Mistle Thrush,16,Monksdale Road,1,Moorhen. Home Feeders:Grey Wagtail,1,Mourning Dove,2,Mute Swan,10,Newton St Loe,20,Newton st Loe.,2,Night heron,5,Northern Brown,1,Nuthatch,27,Orange tip,2,Osprey,1,Ospreys,2,Otmoor,1,Oystercatcher,6,Oystercatcher Plus Painted Lady,1,Painted Lady,4,Pallid Swift,1,Patch,39,Peacock,6,Pearl Bordered,1,perawat profesional,1,Peregrin Falcon,1,Peregrine,2,Peregrine Falcon,6,Peregrine Falcons.,1,Photography News,12,Photography Tips,27,Pied Billed Grebe,1,Pied flycatcher,1,Pied Wagtail,10,Pink Footed Goose,1,Pintail,5,Pochard,2,portland,1,Portland Bill,3,Priddy,2,Priddy Mineries,1,Purple Emperor,2,Purple Hairstreak,2,Purple heron,6,Purple Sandpiper,1,Purple Swamphen,6,radipole,4,Raven,13,Red Admiral,10,Red admiral Yellowhammer,1,Red Breasted Merganser,1,Red Cardinal,1,Red Kite,4,Red knobbed coot,2,Red Legged Partridge,1,Red-Masked Parrot,1,Red-Rumped Swallow,1,Red-Tailed Hawk,1,Red-Winged Blackbird,1,Redshank,3,Redstart,1,Redstarts,1,Redwing,9,Redwing's,1,Reed Bunting,2,Reed Bunting. Oystercatcher,1,Reed Heron,1,Reed Warbler,4,Reef Egret,1,Ring- billed Gull,1,Ring-Billed Gull,1,Ringed Ouzel,1,Ringed Plover,1,Ringlet,6,Ringlets,1,Robin,1,rodborough,1,Rook,4,rspb,1,Ruddy Shelduck,1,Ruff,3,Sand Lizard.,1,Sand Martin,2,Sand Point,1,sandbay,1,Sandpoint,2,Sandwich Tern,1,Sardinan warbler,2,Sardinian Warbler,3,Scaup,2,Scotch Argus,1,Scoter,2,Sedge Warbler,5,seo,1,Serin,4,Severn Beach,1,Shapwick,1,Shapwick Great White Egrets,1,Shapwick Heath,1,Shelduck,5,short eared Owl,3,Shoveler,3,Shoveller,3,Silver Spotted,1,Silver Spotted Skipper,2,Silver Studded Blue,1,Silver Washed Frit,1,Silver Washed Fritillary,5,Siskin,2,Six Spotted Burnet,1,Skylark,23,slimbridge,8,Slow,1,Sm Skipper,1,Small Blue,1,Small Copper,4,Small Heath,4,Small Pearl Bordered,1,Small Skipper,3,Small White,5,Smew,1,Smooth,1,Snakes,1,Snipe,8,Somerset,1,somerset levels,1,Somerset Levels.,1,Song Thrush,12,South Glos,1,Sparrowhawk,14,Sparrowhawk 1,1,Speckled Wood,3,Spoonbill,2,Spotless Starling,2,Spotted Crake,1,Spotted Flycatcher,14,Spotted Flycatchers,1,Spotted Redshank,1,Squacco Heron,1,St Johns Church,2,st.johns,1,Starling,6,Stella's Jay,1,stilt,2,Stock Dove,20,Stone curlew,4,Stonechat,12,Swallowtail,1,Swift,13,Tawny Owl,2,Teal,19,Teal.,1,teknik dasar,2,Tern,1,Terns,1,tick,1,tips,75,Tog Hill,1,Tortoiseshell,1,Treecreeper,11,Tufted Duck,8,Tufted Duck. Small Pearl Bordered Fritillaries,1,Turnstone,1,Turtle Dove,2,Uphill,3,Veined White,1,Velvet,1,Wall,1,Water Pipit,1,Water Rail,4,Waxwing,3,Western Reef Heron,2,Westhay,1,weston Lock,1,Weston Super Mare,1,Weymouth,3,Wheatear,8,Whimbrel,1,Whinchat,2,White Admiral,1,White Crowned Sparrow,1,White Fronted Goose,3,White Letter Hairstreak,1,White Pigeon,1,White Stork,1,White Wags,1,White-Breasted Nuthatch,1,Whites,1,Whitethroat,17,Whitethroat male,1,Whitethroat. Clouded Yellow,1,Whooper Swan,1,Wigeon,10,Willet,1,Willow Warbler,9,Wood Pigeon,2,Wood White,2,Woodchat Shrike,5,Woodpecker,1,Yellow Wagtail,1,Yellow-Legged Gull,1,Yellowhammer,25,Zitting Cisticola,2,
ltr
item
Hara Creative: Is Photography Art?
Is Photography Art?
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgmjnlZhIIAzkWlE1tercpas3TWPFA1cGKI5MpKPjdokZCOP8Qw-JhavxsYZ2LaOhJWEh6rsb6CZiipnE2PMyfhIh6uORQWRxVUbZ_aIFQ-bNMPVbTpD7GHFb-_4aQSj_Di8in8AcU9I4U/s1600/sdvdf.jpg
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgmjnlZhIIAzkWlE1tercpas3TWPFA1cGKI5MpKPjdokZCOP8Qw-JhavxsYZ2LaOhJWEh6rsb6CZiipnE2PMyfhIh6uORQWRxVUbZ_aIFQ-bNMPVbTpD7GHFb-_4aQSj_Di8in8AcU9I4U/s72-c/sdvdf.jpg
Hara Creative
https://haragrupcreative.blogspot.com/2013/12/is-photography-art.html
https://haragrupcreative.blogspot.com/
http://haragrupcreative.blogspot.com/
http://haragrupcreative.blogspot.com/2013/12/is-photography-art.html
true
8493898840061597540
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy